Elvira’s House of Horrors | Stern Pinball Review
· Lazarvs

ELVIRA’S HOUSE OF HORRORS | BUY THE MANSION. THE DEAD ARE INCLUDED.
For sale: charming 1930s mansion, three floors, swimming pool, garage, outbuildings, family crypt, a few gargoyles and enough gothic decoration to make your real-estate agent lose consciousness on arrival. The price seems surprisingly reasonable given the amount of space.
One minor detail missing from the listing: the property is haunted down to its foundations.
Welcome to Elvira’s place.
With Elvira’s House of Horrors, Stern brings Cassandra Peterson back under glass in 2019, thirty years after Elvira and the Party Monsters and twenty-three years after Scared Stiff. Dennis Nordman returns to the character and gives her what may be the perfect setting this time: a mansion full of occupants who have been dead long enough for a conventional eviction procedure to seem wildly optimistic. The rooms trigger the Haunts, the crypt houses the DeadHeads, the garage prepares its multiballs and twenty-six monuments to B-movie cinema feed the ruleset.
The reveal did not convince me at all. The playfield looked too open, almost empty in places, and the toys seemed less spectacular than I expected from a third machine devoted to Elvira. I was wrong. House of Horrors comes alive once you understand that the mansion, the crypt, the garage, the trunk, the windows, the gargoyles and even the back door have all been given real jobs. Nothing seems overwhelmingly impressive on its own. Once the game starts, the entire property begins to work.
Gameplay: Open House, Fatalities Possible
Dennis Nordman delivers a very open layout that gives the ball a huge amount of room to breathe. Two ramps, three bumpers, several orbits and the various entrances into the mansion create a playfield that is mechanically far less crowded than the artwork initially suggests. Ball movement is pleasant, the major trajectories become easy to identify after a few games and the available space allows several objectives to coexist without forcing every shot through the same narrow funnel.
The real pleasure comes from how the different areas overlap. You can work on a Haunt in the mansion, prepare a DeadHead in the crypt, advance the garage or collect something from Junk in the Trunk without waiting for one system to finish before touching the next. The machine gradually encourages a style of play where several problems begin to coexist. As the game progresses, the house fills with more and more things demanding attention until your property viewing starts to resemble an emergency response.
Even the skill shot has real personality. The standard version aims for the lanes feeding the bumpers, while the Secret Skill Shot sends the ball directly behind the mansion through the Back Door and immediately starts a Haunt. Locked balls allow another skill shot attempt, so the mechanic can return several times during the same game. A perfectly questionable joke therefore becomes a genuinely useful progression tool. At Elvira’s, bad taste works for a living.
Ruleset & Progression: Every Room Hides an Administrative Corpse
The mansion is literally the game’s menu. Before starting a Haunt, the flipper buttons allow you to select a window, with each room linked to one of the films used by the machine. Once inside, the mission becomes timed and asks for the required shots to complete the sequence. Collected film reels then feed the Haunt-O-Meter, eventually leading toward Trailer Trash Bonus Round, while the broader progression opens the major objectives.
Several parallel systems orbit around that central structure. The crypt develops the DeadHead family: one shot opens the vault, another wakes an occupant, and the bash toy then needs several hits before the resident is encouraged to return to a lifestyle more appropriate for their legal status. The garage uses a tombstone-shaped drop target before locking balls and feeding several multiballs. Junk in the Trunk adds objects and the Skeleton Key, required to open certain locked rooms in the mansion. The gargoyles fill Garg-Oil-Gauge, switches charge Freak Fryer, the orbits advance Drive Me Crazy, and other objectives such as Unhappy Hour, Wild Market Hurry Up, Pool Party, Dance Fever, Make Out Mayhem, Scream Test and Run For Your Life keep adding more layers to the party.
That amount of content could easily have turned the code into a mess. Lyman Sheats avoids the trap through stacking. House of Horrors does not ask you to finish one task neatly before earning the right to start another: several progressions can be prepared, triggered and layered together. House Party is a good example. Reaching half of the Haunts starts a four-ball multiball centred around the mansion, with moving jackpots and a rotating roof whose symbols alter certain interactions. I never reached The Attic or Director’s Cut during my time with the machine, so I am not going to manufacture an opinion about them. Everything before that already says plenty about the depth of this particular property.
Rhythm: The Later the Party Gets, the More the Neighbours Call the Police
House of Horrors starts much more calmly than its ruleset might suggest. The first few minutes are often spent understanding where the rooms are, what the crypt is preparing and how the different areas communicate. Then the layers begin to pile up. A Haunt starts, a DeadHead waits in the crypt, the garage moves closer to readiness and another side objective is already demanding attention.
The rhythm gains density rather than relying on pure speed. House of Horrors does not need to turn the ball into a permanent projectile to create intensity. The biggest peaks arrive when several systems converge, especially during multiballs and stacked modes. The relatively open playfield then becomes extremely useful because it leaves enough space to keep reading the ball just as the code begins multiplying the problems.
The result feels like a party gradually falling apart. You enter the house with a few missions to complete and end up with several corpses awake, four balls on the playfield, a roof spinning overhead and Elvira still commenting on the disaster. For once, losing control of the evening was probably part of the plan.
Theme & Immersion: A Haunted House Where Every Room Pays Rent
Theme integration is one of House of Horrors’ major achievements. The mansion is not sitting at the back of the playfield simply to give the machine a pretty silhouette: its windows select the Haunts, its ramp contributes directly to gameplay, its roof rotates and its various openings structure progression. The crypt develops a separate ruleset, the garage contains the locks and the trunk distributes useful items. Even the Back Door has more to do than deliver the joke.
The twenty-six films used by the code are not just a bank of clips thrown onto the display either. A Bucket of Blood, Attack of the Giant Leeches, Manos: The Hands of Fate, Night of the Living Dead and this magnificent collection of B-movie cinema feed the Haunts and give the mansion coherent material to work with. House of Horrors understands Elvira perfectly: the goal was never to make horror frightening, but to celebrate dubious monsters, deliberate bad taste, double entendres and films that occasionally look as though a second day of shooting might have helped.
Greg Freres pushes that identity extremely far through the artwork. His fine, caricatured and deeply retro style fills the playfield with characters, chains, stonework, lightning and details that can make the first few games visually overwhelming. But that density fits Elvira perfectly, and it gradually stops interfering once the game architecture becomes familiar. Jerry Thompson continues the same work with a soundtrack mixing horror, theremin, jazz and Cuban influences, while Cassandra Peterson naturally provides the irreplaceable ingredient: Elvira herself. Personally, this combination of camp, innuendo and carefully controlled bad taste is exactly my kind of thing.
A Bucket Of Blood (1959)
Attack Of The Giant Leeches (1959)
Beast From Haunted Cave (1959)
Don’t Look In The Basement (1973)
Eegah (1962)
Hercules And The Captive Women (1963)
I Eat Your Skin (1964)
Jesse James Meets Frankenstein’s Daughter (1965)
Lady Frankenstein (1971)
Manos: The Hands Of Fate (1966)
Monster From A Prehistoric Planet (1967)
Night Of The Living Dead (1968)
Santa Claus Conquers The Martians (1964)
Scared To Death (1947)
Teenagers From Outer Space (1959)
The Brain That Wouldn’t Die (1962)
The Giant Gila Monster (1959)
The Killer Shrews (1959)
The Manster (1959)
The Satanic Rites Of Dracula (1973)
The Terror (1963)
The Wasp Woman (1960)
The Werewolf Of Washington (1973)
The Wild Women Of Wongo (1958)
Tormented (1960)
Untamed Women (1952)
Readability & Mastery: The Floor Plan Arrives After You Move In
The first few games can be confusing. The paradox comes from a mechanically open playfield covered in extremely dense artwork, with the code quickly adding several parallel systems on top. At first, the windows look like windows, the crypt looks like a crypt and the garage looks like that dark area where something will probably end badly.
Then the house starts making sense. The mansion becomes the main map, the crypt represents an independent progression path, the garage prepares the multiballs, Junk in the Trunk supplies its items and the windows clearly show the available missions. What initially looked decorative becomes functional. Readability is not immediate, but it improves dramatically once the structure of the machine is understood.
Mastery then comes from using that architecture rather than simply following it. Choosing the right Haunt, exploiting the Back Door, preparing several systems simultaneously and deciding when to stack modes turns a decent game into a genuine construction exercise. The challenge therefore goes beyond shot accuracy: you need to understand how to make the entire house work at the same time without ending up in the crypt yourself.
Longevity: The Lease Runs for a Very Long Time
House of Horrors contains a considerable amount of content before even reaching its most advanced goals. The Haunts, twenty-six films, DeadHeads, Haunt-O-Meter, Junk in the Trunk, multiple multiballs and the entire collection of side modes create many possible directions during a game. The ability to advance several systems simultaneously also prevents the ruleset from becoming a rigid succession of missions.
The longevity is not based on quantity alone. The systems interact enough that learning the machine genuinely changes how a game is built. The better you know the house, the less you wander into rooms at random and the more you prepare their collision. That gives the machine another layer of life: discovering a mode is one step, learning what to stack it with is another.
I never reached some of the most advanced content, and that fact itself says something useful about the amount of material available. House of Horrors still had locked doors when I stopped playing. In a market where some codes reveal their entire architecture fairly quickly, having a few rooms sealed off on the top floor is a good sign.
Physical Machine: No Pro. The Coffin Comes Fully Equipped.
Stern makes an unusual decision here: there is no Pro version. The range begins with Premium and then moves up to LE and CE, while the playfield remains identical. Buying the least expensive version therefore does not mean giving up an essential game mechanism. Three bumpers, Beast Booster Spinner, Junk in the Trunk, four animated gargoyles, two ramps, the crypt with its bash toy, the RGB mansion with moving ramp, secret door, drop target and rotating roof, Hand of Fate, Open the Trunk and the up-kicker are all present from Premium onward.
The mansion and crypt naturally dominate the composition. Their construction is not mechanically extravagant, but the volumes, artwork and lighting give them enough presence to become genuine set pieces. More importantly, they work. The mansion changes function, the crypt opens, the roof rotates, the gargoyles move and the trunk contributes to progression. House of Horrors uses its mechanisms to feed the game rather than to fill out a sales brochure.
Hand of Fate captures that philosophy perfectly. Targets on the right light a feature at the left outlane; when the ball drops there, a wheel appears on the LCD and the lockbar button is used to stop it, with possible rewards including Ball Save, multiball extensions, points or a bonus multiplier. Even a potential drain becomes another interaction. Elvira apparently refuses to let anyone leave without selling them one last attraction.
LE and CE mainly add the collector layer with dedicated finishes, mirror backglass, anti-reflective glass, shaker, artblades and upgraded audio equipment. In the original test, the CE was limited to fifty machines and included a card signed by Cassandra Peterson as well as a fragment of red leather from the original couch used on her show. Once you start collecting pieces of Elvira’s sofa, pinball has officially moved beyond being a simple hobby.
Editorial Verdict: The Reveal Looked Empty. The House Absolutely Wasn’t.
Elvira’s House of Horrors made me change my mind after the reveal. I saw a playfield that looked too open, relatively modest mechanisms and a machine that might rely far too heavily on its character. Playing it revealed the opposite. The space Dennis Nordman leaves available allows Lyman Sheats to install an extremely dense ruleset without strangling ball movement.
The success comes from the function given to every important part of the scenery. The mansion organises the Haunts, the crypt develops the DeadHeads, the garage feeds the multiballs, Junk in the Trunk provides useful items, the Back Door becomes a skill shot and even the gargoyles eventually contribute to the game. Theme, layout and code all use the same vocabulary. That is what I expect from successful integration.
House of Horrors does require several games before that intelligence becomes obvious. The artwork can overwhelm the initial read and the amount of information makes the opening sessions less intuitive than they might otherwise be. But once the floor plan is understood, that weakness almost turns into a strength: you gradually discover that many things you dismissed as decoration had already been working behind the scenes.
The most important quality is still personality. Turn off the sound, hide the translite and forget the name on the cabinet for a few minutes: the mansion, the crypt, the questionable jokes, the terrible movies and the beautifully organised chaos still scream Elvira. It is not Stern’s fastest game, nor the one with the most extravagant mechanical spectacle. It does something much harder: it turns its character completely into pinball.
Scared Stiff gave Elvira a major place in pinball history. House of Horrors finally builds the home she deserved. It is enormous, just vulgar enough, full of dead people and almost certainly impossible to insure.
I’m signing the papers.
Thus have I spoken

The author
LazarvsFondateur de Pinball Xperience. Joueur. Collectionneur. Créateur. Le flipper comme jeu, culture et industrie. PLAY. LEARN. CONNECT.
View profile