Pinball Xperience

Toy Story 4 JJP | Full Pinball Review

· Lazarvs

Toy Story 4 JJP | Full Pinball Review
jersey jack pinballpinball xperienceTS4Toy Story 4 pinballToy Story 4 JJP reviewtest flipper Toy Story 4Pat Lawlor Toy Story 4Toy Story 4 pinball gameplayDuke Caboom pinballGabby Gabby pinballToy Story 4 Tiki PinballToy Story 4 Limited EditionToy Story 4 Collector EditionToy Story 4 pinball reviewtest flipperpinball reviewPX TestToy Story 4

TOY STORY 4 | PAT LAWLOR PUTS HIS TOYS AWAY ONE LAST TIME

Toy Story 4 arrived at Jersey Jack Pinball in June 2022 with several problems already waiting before the first ball was launched. The price pushed well beyond what many players were used to at the time, the licence focused on a fourth film that did not carry the same emotional weight for everyone as the first three, and part of the community looked at the playfield in photos and immediately decided that a pinball machine built around toys somehow lacked toys. The discussion could easily have ended inside that familiar modern-pinball ritual where a machine is judged from a phone screen with the confidence of a surgeon operating from the cafeteria. Then people actually started playing it, and Toy Story 4 proved far more interesting than its launch controversy suggested.

The machine also holds a particular place in Jersey Jack history: it became Pat Lawlor’s final commercial game design before retirement. After The Addams Family, Twilight Zone, Whirlwind, FunHouse, Monopoly and Dialed In!, Lawlor ended his career with a Disney/Pixar licence built around a carnival, toys and a much broader audience than the most demanding modern pinball machines usually target. The result does not try to turn Toy Story into a strategic labyrinth. Lawlor instead returns to an idea he had understood for decades: a playfield that can be read quickly, several physical attractions that are easy to identify and enough systems beneath the surface to prevent accessibility from turning into emptiness. JJP’s official support page currently lists software version 2.04, which also allows the machine to be judged well beyond the noise of its original launch.

Gameplay: Pat Lawlor Turns the Playfield Into a Carnival

Toy Story 4 uses a design that immediately prioritises movement and clearly separated areas. The major trajectories are easy to read, physical objectives occupy distinct positions and the ball moves with a generosity that feels unusual within a JJP catalogue often associated with massive rulesets and demanding games. Lawlor aims for a family machine in the strongest sense of the term: a casual player can understand several actions during the first game, while an experienced player still has enough choices to build something more deliberate. The philosophy sits much closer to The Addams Family than Twilight Zone. There are plenty of systems, but the machine does not ask for a doctorate before allowing anyone to enjoy them.

The playfield also uses several ways to disrupt that movement. The Take A Chance wheel behaves like a spinning disc capable of changing the path of a ball that crosses it, Gabby Gabby rises as a bash toy once prepared, and Duke Caboom turns a stunt ramp into a real jump toward the illuminated ring in the back panel. None of these mechanisms reinvents pinball, and several openly recall ideas Lawlor or other designers had used before, but their value comes from the way they fit into the overall movement. Duke Caboom’s jump remains especially effective: the ball genuinely leaves the surface and gives the player an immediate physical reward that works far better than an animation celebrating the same objective on a screen.

The main progression revolves around seven major objectives inspired by the film and its carnival setting: Road Trip Multiball, Quick Buzz Multiball, Rescue Forky, Carnival Multiball, Super Spinners, Duke Caboom Jump and Bo Peep Super Loops. Completing them leads toward Meet Me At The Carousel, the higher destination that gives longer games a clear direction. Around that central structure sit Gabby Gabby, Tiki Party Pinball, the Take A Chance wheel and several Hurry-Ups. The structure is easy to remember because every branch is linked to a character, attraction or action that is visually identifiable on the playfield.

That initial simplicity hides a more interesting game once several progressions begin to advance together. The Woody and Bo Peep spinners feed their own objective, tickets are spent on carnival games, Duke Caboom requires his dedicated work and Road Trip or Quick Buzz establish their own multiballs. Toy Story 4 never reaches the strategic density of The Hobbit or some of JJP’s more recent machines, but that is not what it is trying to do. Pat Lawlor prefers several short, readable and rewarding objectives that can be understood independently, then allows their accumulation to lead naturally toward the endgame. The approach makes the machine welcoming without reducing it to a collection of shots with no destination.

Rhythm: One Attraction Starts Before the Previous One Has Left the Park

The rhythm works like a carnival where several attractions remain visible and available at once. The player can pursue Forky, prepare a multiball, work on the spinners or aim for Duke Caboom without waiting for a long narrative mode to release the rest of the playfield. That permanent availability gives Toy Story 4 a light energy, very different from machines where the whole game appears suspended around a single active mode. Multiballs naturally provide the strongest accelerations, while the Take A Chance disc and certain returns introduce enough disorder to break up sequences that might otherwise become too clean.

The ten-inch playfield display interrupts that continuity more noticeably. It works well when showing local information, animations and progression, but Tiki Party Pinball exposes the limits of the concept when the screen tries to become a separate game inside the game. Controlling a virtual mini-pinball with the cabinet buttons sounded entertaining on paper; in practice, the lack of fluidity observed during testing turns the curiosity into an interruption fairly quickly. The idea remains original and can even unlock its own multiball, but Toy Story 4 works much better when the display supports the real ball rather than asking it to temporarily leave centre stage.

Theme & Immersion: JJP Opens the Toy Chest

Visually, Toy Story 4 uses exactly the kind of licence that allows JJP to indulge its strengths. The playfield is filled with references, figures, small graphical details and inserts without obscuring the major gameplay areas. The custom apron, with magnetic and removable instruction cards, reinforces the sense of an object designed down to details many manufacturers still treat as purely functional surfaces. Once the machine is switched on, the hundreds of RGB LEDs turn the playfield into a miniature carnival where colour naturally supports a licence that has no reason to pursue restraint.

The main limitation comes less from execution than from scope. JJP genuinely produced a Toy Story 4 machine rather than a broad celebration of all four films. Woody, Buzz and several historical characters remain present, You’ve Got a Friend in Me immediately reconnects the experience with the larger saga and Pixar’s legacy still carries much of the emotional weight, but the fourth film provides the dominant narrative framework through Forky, Gabby Gabby, Duke Caboom and the carnival. For players whose attachment is rooted mostly in Andy’s room and the earlier films, that choice creates a small emotional distance that even excellent production values cannot completely erase.

Audio softens part of that distance through music, original callouts and the carnival atmosphere surrounding progression. The 27-inch main LCD uses scenes from the film effectively and several animations are very polished, even when deliberately minimalist. The coexistence of that display with the ten-inch screen can occasionally split the player’s attention, however. Toy Story 4 is strongest when the two displays clearly prioritise their information rather than competing for the same glance.

Readability & Mastery: A Child Can Understand It, a Good Player Still Has to Finish It

Accessibility is one of Toy Story 4’s clearest strengths. Objectives are physically distinct, rewards arrive quickly and the major progressions use references that are easy to remember. A casual player quickly understands that Gabby Gabby needs to be hit, Duke Caboom needs to jump and carnival games require tickets. This intuitive reading makes the machine easy to share with children, visitors or inexperienced players without turning every game into a training session.

Mastery depends less on brutally difficult shots than on managing the large number of opportunities efficiently. An ambitious game requires the player to avoid wasting progress, complete the seven major objectives and convert sequences correctly before losing the ball. Strong players will understand the overall structure faster than on JJP’s deepest machines and will also identify its recurring patterns sooner. Toy Story 4 deliberately chooses a shorter learning curve and faster gratification. That decision greatly broadens its audience, but it also reduces the amount of strategic mystery still waiting after several hundred games.

Longevity: Wanting to Play Again Matters More Than the Number of Unknown Rules

Toy Story 4 does not build longevity around a huge reserve of hidden content. The seven main objectives appear quickly, the physical features become familiar after a handful of sessions and the broader structure is understood much earlier than on The Hobbit or Pirates of the Caribbean. Repetition can therefore become an issue for players whose enjoyment depends mainly on constantly discovering new missions or a ruleset that takes months to fully understand.

Its retention comes instead from how easy the machine is to enjoy again. Toy Story 4 can be left alone for several weeks, then played again without having to mentally reconstruct twenty forgotten systems. Multiballs, Duke Caboom, Gabby Gabby, the spinners and the wheel provide enough physical variety for short sessions, while Meet Me At The Carousel gives more committed players a clear destination. That ability to function at several levels of involvement fits the family positioning perfectly: the experienced player, the child and the visiting friend are not necessarily looking for the same thing, but each can use the playfield in a coherent way.

Physical Machine: The Playfield Was Never Empty, It Was Simply Less Demonstrative Than Expected

The early criticism about a lack of toys does not survive a serious look at the playfield. Toy Story 4 includes the rising Gabby Gabby mechanism, the Take A Chance spinning disc, Duke Caboom’s jump, the Woody and Bo Peep spinners, locks, Forky targets and especially the ten-inch display integrated directly into the playfield. Part of the problem came from expectation: a licence built entirely around toys naturally encouraged people to imagine a surface covered in giant motorised sculptures. Pat Lawlor instead uses several more discreet mechanisms, some hidden, whose value becomes obvious during play rather than in the first promotional photograph.

The machine was released only as Limited Edition and Collector’s Edition. The LE carries its Imagination Blue armour and the complete gameplay package, while the Collector’s Edition raises the presentation through red finishing, dedicated cosmetic treatment and the fibre-optic topper featuring Duke Caboom in motion. JJP announced 5,000 LE units and 1,000 CE units, placing Toy Story 4 exclusively in the high-end range from the beginning. That strategy explains much of the pricing criticism surrounding the 2022 launch, but the original price contributes very little to evaluating the game today. The relevant point is that the difference between the two editions mainly concerns finish and spectacle around the same gameplay foundation.

The playfield display remains the most debatable hardware choice. As a secondary information screen, it works and fits the carnival theme extremely well. As an interface for Tiki Party Pinball, it feels more like an idea that sounded better during development than during a long session. Toy Story 4 therefore demonstrates that a pinball machine can integrate two displays, hundreds of LEDs and a substantial amount of technology without every innovation automatically reaching the same level of relevance.

Editorial Verdict: Pat Lawlor’s Final Game Would Rather Play Than Prove Something

Toy Story 4 was almost designed to disappoint part of its audience before release. Some players wanted a celebration of the entire saga and received a game centred mainly on the fourth film; others expected a playfield covered in monumental toys; many mainly saw a price that pushed the financial discussion ahead of the gameplay itself. Beneath those expectations, Pat Lawlor had built a far more coherent machine than the early photographs suggested: accessible, colourful, generous, filled with small interactions and capable of welcoming players who have no interest in studying a rules map for an hour before having fun.

Its limitations are equally clear. Tiki Party Pinball does not fulfil the promise of its enormous screen, strategic depth remains below JJP’s most ambitious machines and the exclusive focus on Toy Story 4 gives up part of the emotional potential of a licence that now spans several generations. Visual spectacle and production quality cannot completely compensate for those limitations for players who primarily want a deeply complex machine to explore for years.

The strength of Toy Story 4 comes from the fact that it does not pretend to be that machine. Pat Lawlor does not end his career by trying to break a record for modes, shots or interlocking systems. He returns to a design where objects make sense, where a ramp can be enjoyable simply because it launches Duke Caboom into the air and where a casual player can share a game with an enthusiast without feeling as though they are using a simplified version of the same experience. His final machine does not try to become Twilight Zone 2 under a Pixar licence; it returns instead to pinball’s older ability to bring several generations around one playfield while allowing the rules to reveal themselves without ever blocking enjoyment.

With enough distance from the launch, that choice gives Toy Story 4 a much clearer place in the Jersey Jack catalogue. It is neither the company’s deepest machine nor its most mechanically audacious, and the tablet will remain an innovation only partially fulfilled. It is still one of JJP’s easiest games to place in front of almost any player and watch it work immediately. For Pat Lawlor’s final design, finishing with a toy chest capable of bringing children, parents and pinheads together around the same machine feels far more coherent than one final demonstration of complexity.

Thus I have spoken.

Lazarvs

The author

Lazarvs

Fondateur de Pinball Xperience. Joueur. Collectionneur. Créateur. Le flipper comme jeu, culture et industrie. PLAY. LEARN. CONNECT.

View profile