Pinball Xperience

Elvira’s House of Horrors Topper Review | Is It Worth $999 ?

· Lazarvs

Elvira’s House of Horrors Topper Review | Is It Worth $999 ?
stern pinballpinball xperienceElvira House of Horrors pinballtopper flipperpinball topperElvira's House of Horrors

Elvira’s House of Horrors arrived in September 2019 and it was a hit. One year later, Stern slapped a crypt on top of it and asked $999.99 for the privilege of taking it home. And that was a different story! Well yes, back to the future of the past in the passive form of the imperfect subjunctive: in 2020, that number hurt a hell of a lot more than it does today.

At the time, the four-figure topper had not yet become the norm for this curious accessory Stern can now sell for as much as $1,999.99 on a machine like Foo Fighters. So when the Elvira topper came out at $999.99, the community immediately opened a crisis management unit. “Are they fucking kidding us?”, “As long as there are suckers willing to buy them!”, “They’re insane, they’ll never sell any!”, “A thousand bucks for a piece of plastic!”, “That costs more than a PS5!” Blah, blah, and blah all over again.

Once again, the community reacted with its gut before reaching for a calculator. $1,000 for a topper, yes, that is expensive. Very expensive. But are you required to buy it? No. Does its existence increase the price of the pinball machine you already own? No again. Stern is offering an optional accessory at a price some people consider absurd and others acceptable. The market will then do what it generally does very well: decide whether enough customers are willing to buy it.

And above all, comparing its price with a PS5 makes absolutely no sense. Production volumes, markets, development costs, industrial processes and economies of scale have nothing in common. Putting “$1,000 topper” next to “$500 console” simply gives people two numbers that are easy to understand. Technically, the comparison proves nothing. On social media, however, it works beautifully.

Because technology is not even the point. The point is your reaction. A PS5 contains a processor, GPU, memory, SSD, power supply, controller and enough technology to make your $1,000 illuminated crypt suddenly look as though it was handcrafted by a Tibetan artisan between two goats. Perfect. Your brain has just received exactly the information it needed to conclude within three seconds that Stern is taking the piss.

And that is how the magnificent intellectual shortcuts social media adores are born. One absurd comparison, two prices, instantly understandable outrage, a few hundred comments and the machine is running. While everyone explains that nobody will ever buy the thing, Facebook quietly counts the engagement.

Except that four years later, Stern would be selling even more expensive toppers.

So let’s take a closer look. First for what it was: a snapshot of the moment Stern began testing just how far the perceived value of an official accessory could be pushed on a particularly desirable machine. Then for what it became: an accessory whose very legitimacy is barely questioned anymore. The debate has moved. We no longer really ask why Stern sells toppers. We ask how much Stern is going to dare charge for the next one.

As for the money, time travel has changed nothing: $999.99 is still expensive. Very expensive. Now that we have put away the pitchforks, shut down Facebook and left the PS5 alone, there is something fairly simple left to do: look at what you actually got for a thousand bucks.

$1,000, BUT FOR WHAT?

To understand why $999.99 pissed so many people off in 2020, you have to look at what Stern had released immediately before it. Black Knight: Sword of Rage had also received an official topper. Price: $499.99. And for half the money, the thing was hardly shy. The Black Knight helmet was animated, accompanied by a pulsing LED light show and integrated into the game. It extended the character’s presence above the backbox with his voice and animations. In short, for $500, you already had lights, movement and a knight yelling at you, with the added luxury of a little black feather plume on his helmet.

Then Elvira arrived at $999.99.

And in a direct comparison, it is difficult to pretend Stern had simply put twice as much stuff in the box. That is one of the topper’s weaknesses when you place it back in the reality of 2020 instead of looking at it through eyes accustomed to today’s prices. The price doubled. The technological spectacle absolutely did not. The Black Knight topper is actually more demonstrative in terms of animation. Elvira bets on something else: scenery, size, the license and, above all, its exceptional aesthetic integration with House of Horrors.

That distinction matters if you want to judge the product fairly. At launch, $999.99 could not be defended purely through a list of components. If your unit of measurement is “how much stuff moves for every dollar I spend,” Black Knight has already slapped Elvira across the face before she has even had time to crawl out of her crypt.

WELCOME TO THE DEADHEADS

Stern took the Deadhead Family Crypt already present on the House of Horrors playfield and moved the concept upstairs. On the machine, that crypt is a genuine mechanical element: its gate can block the entrance, open to reveal the Deadhead you need to hit or allow the ball to enter the mausoleum. The topper therefore takes something the player already knows and extends it above the backbox.

Visually, that is much smarter than yet another ELVIRA logo glowing red. You get the gargoyles from the crypt façade, a tombstone that opens to reveal Elvira screaming in terror, internal lighting and the whole carnival-mausoleum aesthetic that fits the machine perfectly. It does not try to become the new centerpiece of Elvira’s House of Horrors. It makes the scenery bigger.

More importantly, the topper is controlled by the machine. Update 0.99.0 from August 2020 explicitly added topper drivers, tests, lamps and the topper coil, both during gameplay and in attract mode. So this is not a $1,000 funeral night-light repeating the same sequence from morning until night. It has behaviors outside of gameplay and reactions while you are playing.

Attract mode matters on an accessory like this. Statistically, a topper spends far more time sitting above a pinball machine waiting for its next player than it does above an active game. It therefore also needs to make the machine feel alive when it is simply switched on in a gameroom. The lighting and animations prevent it from becoming a giant dead lump of plastic sitting on top of the backbox.

During gameplay, the integration becomes more contextual. Stern officially built the topper around the Deadhead Family Crypt and Elvira’s appearances as you progress through the House of Horrors. The idea is not to make you stare at the ceiling while the ball drains straight down the middle, but to use the topper as an extension of the staging. Thankfully, because dying while watching a tomb open above your pinball machine would be getting a little too conceptual.

BLACK KNIGHT DID MORE, ELVIRA FITS ITS MACHINE BETTER

This is ultimately where the two toppers head in different directions. Black Knight is more interested in spectacle. Its animated helmet, pulsing flame lighting and the physical presence of the character immediately draw the eye. Elvira is less impressive when isolated from the machine. Put both toppers alone on a table and the difference in price becomes fairly brutal. But a topper is not supposed to sit alone on a table.

Once installed on House of Horrors, Elvira gains a tremendous amount of ground. The mansion already dominates the rear of the playfield with its RGB windows and rotating roof. The topper closes the composition at the very top. Your eye travels from the playfield, climbs the mansion, crosses the backbox and ends inside the mausoleum. It is less “look what my topper can do” and more “look at my machine.” And with hindsight, I really like that approach.

SIX YEARS LATER, $999 DOESN’T LOOK QUITE THE SAME

In 2020, Elvira was the $1,000 topper that made everyone scream. Today, Stern still officially lists it at $999.99. In the meantime, the psychological barrier that once seemed insane has become little more than another milestone in the price evolution of the modern topper.

That obviously does not turn $999.99 into a bargain. A price does not suddenly become reasonable simply because somebody later figured out how to charge even more. But our frame of reference has changed. More importantly, Elvira has aged rather well because its appeal was never built entirely around a technological gimmick destined to look ridiculous five years later. It still has presence today. Just like Elvira.

On a House of Horrors, and even more so on an LE, Signature or visually loaded Blood Red Kiss, it finishes the machine beautifully. Without it, Elvira is obviously still Elvira. With it, the silhouette feels as though it finally reaches the end of its own idea. The House of Horrors no longer stops at the playfield or backbox. It gains another floor and ends inside the Deadheads’ crypt.

So in 2020, looking at Black Knight for $499.99, then looking at Elvira for $999.99 and wondering where the extra $500 had gone was entirely legitimate. It was actually an excellent question. In 2026, the answer is rather amusing: it was not in the technology. It was already in what Stern would learn to sell for increasingly extravagant prices, the ultimate finishing touch for a machine its owner already possesses and very much wants to make even more spectacular.

Thus have I spoken.

Lazarvs

The author

Lazarvs

Fondateur de Pinball Xperience. Joueur. Collectionneur. Créateur. Le flipper comme jeu, culture et industrie. PLAY. LEARN. CONNECT.

View profile