Pinball Xperience

Pokémon Stern | Full Pinball Review

· Lazarvs

Pokémon Stern | Full Pinball Review
stern pinballmodern pinballgaming culturepinball xperiencepop culturepinball collectionbuying pinball machinesStern Insider ConnectedStern pinball reviewtest flipper SternPokémon pinballPokémon Stern reviewtest flipper PokémonPokémon pinball machinePokémon PremiumPokémon LEPokémon Arena pinballPokémon Stern gameplayPokémon Insider ConnectedPokémon pinball codetest flipperpinball reviewPX TestPokémon

POKÉMON | THE PINBALL MACHINE THAT FINALLY TAUGHT ME TO CATCH THEM

Pokémon and I managed the remarkable feat of sharing the same planet for almost thirty years without ever really meeting. I knew Pikachu, Poké Balls, the cards and the general principle of catching creatures. I had even owned a video game store at a time when I watched kids fight over Pokémon cartridges from the other side of the counter. I understood the scale of the phenomenon perfectly well without ever feeling the slightest desire to take part in it. No anime, no video games, no Game Boy nostalgia and no forgotten childhood binder hidden in an attic. Pokémon simply belonged to a generation other than mine.

Then I had children, and collecting changed sides. They grew up surrounded by video games, pinball machines, science-fiction replicas, Gremlins, Aliens and everything a lifetime spent refusing to completely abandon your passions can eventually accumulate. They inherited the taste for universes and collecting without necessarily adopting mine. Pokémon entered the house through them. I could have explained that X-Or looked cooler, that Spectreman would destroy Pikachu and that the cartoons from my childhood had a soul theirs had somehow lost between two marketing campaigns. In other words, I could have become exactly the old idiot I hated when I was their age. I preferred to watch what they loved.

When Stern quietly let me know that Pokémon was going to become a pinball machine, my son and I did not receive the same piece of information. I saw one of the most powerful licences in the world landing in the hands of the largest pinball manufacturer. He saw two parts of his universe suddenly merge. I put my name down for a Limited Edition before realising that I had just reserved a very expensive machine based on a theme I barely knew. Bad decisions often make good stories, so I decided to catch up on thirty years of Pokémon before the machine arrived.

The anime did not work. Neither did the video games. Then I opened a booster pack with my son and forty years of collecting hit me straight in the face. The plastic tearing open, revealing the cards one by one, the completely irrational hope that the next one might be shiny, rare or simply the card still missing from the binder: I already knew that feeling. Pokémon had invented nothing about my relationship with collecting. It had simply changed the illustrations. A few booster packs later, we were hunting cards together and I had finally found my way in.

The pinball machine would need to do exactly the same thing: not ask me to love Pokémon before playing, but use what makes Pokémon addictive to give me a reason to continue. Discover. Catch. Train. Battle. Travel. On that point, Stern understood the licence with an intelligence that the relatively conventional playfield does not immediately reveal.

Gameplay: Gotta Catch ’Em All, But First You Have to Make the Ramp

Pokémon is built around a deliberately readable architecture. The main shots are easy to identify, two flippers are enough to understand the overall geography and the machine handles what I would call productive mistakes particularly well. Miss a ramp and the ball may still enter another useful area, advance a secondary objective or feed something that will matter later. For a machine whose obvious missions include attracting less experienced players, this is particularly effective: failing to do exactly what you intended does not automatically mean wasting the shot.

The four major shots associated with Bulbasaur, Squirtle, Pikachu and Charmander immediately give the playfield an identity. Three passes through one of them start its Story Mode, each using a different structure. Bulbasaur builds and then collects a pollen value, Squirtle works around the left ramp and the Whirlpool on Premium and LE, Pikachu faces Raichu in a two-ball multiball, while Charmander turns the spinner into the main objective with multipliers built through the other shots. A beginner can simply aim for the Pokémon they want to play; an experienced player is already thinking about a potential multiplier, a value being built and a shot they may exploit much later.

That readability does not make the gameplay shallow. Its sophistication comes less from spectacular geometry than from the way shot values evolve throughout the game. The same trajectories become Story Mode tools, capture shots, TEAM Features, battle objectives, combos or multiplier carriers depending on the context. The playfield therefore changes strategically more than physically. I understand why some players may want a more adventurous layout, but Pokémon would rather let a newcomer quickly understand where to shoot before explaining why that exact same shot may become much more important twenty minutes later.

Ruleset & Progression: Discover, Catch, Train, Battle

The fundamental success of the ruleset can be reduced to four verbs: Discover, Catch, Train, Battle. Pokémon does not use them as attractive labels placed on four conventional modes; they genuinely form the progression loop. Inside a biome, switches advance discovery. When a Pokémon appears, the Pokédex captive ball scans it and starts a CATCH hurry-up. The required shots must then be completed before the Poké Ball lights on the left ramp for the final capture. The more Pokémon you have already caught during the game, the more shots the sequence demands.

Difficulty therefore rises without artificially changing the rules. The first capture teaches the ritual; later ones ask you to execute it better. Pokédex Assist allows up to three assists to be stored and uses the action button to complete certain intermediate shots, but never the final ramp. I particularly like that philosophy: accessibility helps you reach the important moment without stealing the success you wanted to earn yourself.

Catching is not merely about filling a collection. Pokémon then become fighters during Rival Battles. Pikachu starts the battle, but after enough damage has been dealt, the Town Scoop allows the active Pokémon to be changed. Type advantages matter, prior training increases damage and the Training Targets can also heal the active fighter. The licence begins to influence actual decisions: which Pokémon should I send in, when should I switch, when should I heal, when should I spend an Assist and which part of the playfield deserves priority?

Forest, Lake, Desert and Mountain give this loop a long-term direction. Each biome requires exploration, capturing, training and battling before the player can leave. Completing all four regions eventually leads to Pokémon Arena. In the code state documented in this review, the machine therefore finally has a genuine backbone: discover something, catch it, give it functional value, use it, then repeat the cycle with higher stakes.

Rhythm: An Adventure That Keeps Adding Weight to Itself

Pokémon does not rely on permanent frenzy. Its rhythm comes from accumulation. The opening minutes distribute Story Modes, captures, combos and TEAM Features relatively quickly, then every system begins adding weight to the others. A strong ball does not merely become longer; it becomes more valuable. Shot multipliers are installed, some shots remain boosted for the rest of the ball, the team develops and captures gradually demand more work.

Rival Battles create the first major peaks, Team Rocket Multiball provides a more traditional explosion and the Pikachu vs. Charizard and Pikachu vs. Lucario encounters then begin reusing what the game has already built. Charizard is particularly interesting because some of its values are derived from earlier Story Mode performances. The machine begins looking backwards. Something you did much earlier can still affect a major event later in the game.

Pokémon Arena takes that progression far enough to start disrupting the player’s habits. Opponents do not merely require more shots; they alter the conditions of play. Gengar reduces the available lighting information, Metagross reverses the flippers and prevents healing, Talonflame introduces periods of invulnerability and other opponents impose their own constraints. Rhythm then becomes the result of learning: the game teaches you a language over several biomes before deliberately beginning to distort its grammar.

Theme & Immersion: Pokémon Works When It Leaves the Screen and Enters Your Decisions

Pokémon has an enormous advantage: almost everyone instinctively understands its fundamental loop. Stern could have settled for displaying creatures on the LCD while the player completed entirely generic pinball objectives. The game chooses a much more interesting route. Discovering, catching, training and battling become different actions under the glass. The licence stops being decoration and begins organising the game itself.

That integration works best during captures and Rival Battles. A final ramp no longer has only a scoring value when a Pokémon you actually want is waiting behind it. Failure becomes emotional before it becomes mathematical. I have missed shots worth far more points without caring particularly much, then felt completely disproportionate frustration after missing a capture because I wanted that creature. That is exactly where the licence starts changing gameplay: it alters the personal value the player gives to the same physical action.

Visually, Stern is considerably more cautious. The playfield is colourful, readable and instantly recognisable, but a licence with such an enormous bestiary could have supported far more physical presence. Pikachu, the Poké Ball, the Meowth balloon, the Pokédex and the starters provide the necessary landmarks without turning the playfield into a figurine department. I understand the restraint, especially on a machine designed to recruit new players. The collector in me would still have liked to discover far more creatures under the glass.

The audio follows the same philosophy. Voices, effects and assets from the licence immediately give captures, battles and multiballs their identity without trying to turn Pokémon into an artificially adult universe for the benefit of pinball collectors. I am still not a fan of the anime. I never needed to become one. The machine uses its language well enough for me to understand what is happening when the ball acts.

Readability & Mastery: Easy to Understand Does Not Mean Easy to Finish

Pokémon handles onboarding particularly well because it explains why you are playing before it asks you to understand how to optimise. A beginner can choose Pikachu, start a Story Mode, discover a creature and attempt to catch it without knowing half the ruleset. Their game already has meaning. An advanced player can make exactly the same shots while thinking about shot multipliers, TEAM boosts, Berries, future captures or the way certain values may be reused much later.

The Training Targets illustrate this philosophy beautifully. Outside Story Modes, they train a Pokémon. During a Story Mode, they add time. During a Rival Battle, they heal the active fighter. The target retains a coherent thematic identity even though its tactical value changes with context. The player is not memorising three arbitrary functions; they gradually understand what “training” means depending on the state of the game.

The TEAM lanes take this construction even further. They feed four features linked to the starters, each permanently strengthening its associated shot for the rest of the ball and increasing the number of Poké Balls earned there. Story Modes can also install persistent shot multipliers for the ball on particular areas. The longer a strong ball survives, the more the playfield starts becoming the player’s property. Losing eventually hurts because you are no longer losing only a ball; you are losing the tactical investment accumulated on it.

The skill ceiling remains less focused on pure execution than on some much harsher machines. Pokémon aims for a different balance. It allows many systems to advance and then asks the expert player to optimise the way they converge. Difficulty comes from construction, survival over a long ball and the ability to exploit everything you have built correctly.

Longevity: The Pokédex Is a Promise the Pinball Machine Still Needs to Fully Honour

Pokémon naturally has an almost indecent replayability engine: collection. Captures, four biomes, Rival Battles, Eeveelutions hidden inside combo sequences, Story Modes, TEAM Features, shot multipliers and advanced confrontations already provide several reasons to return. A family player can simply hunt for new Pokémon while an advanced player builds multipliers and aims for Arena. Both can share the same machine without playing exactly the same game.

Insider Connected should have made that strength even more obvious. A licence built around “catching them all,” combined with a system capable of identifying a player across machines, looked like the perfect use case for a persistent collection. The launch documented in this review, however, did not immediately deliver the level of presentation and exploitation that such a feature seemed to promise. The commercial potential is obvious, but the PX Score™ has to judge what actually exists, not what a roadmap may eventually deliver.

The Magikarp topper pushes the debate even further because it adds its own persistent progression toward an exclusive Magikarp Multiball. From a design perspective, I love the idea: the topper communicates with captures and becomes a real system rather than an expensive illuminated ornament. Commercially, I am much more uncomfortable. Putting a complete mechanic and a multiball behind an additional paid accessory moves pinball dangerously close to practices we have spent years criticising in video games. The topper may be excellent; its content still cannot increase the depth of the base machine.

Longevity therefore eventually meets the same question as the code. Pokémon already has an extremely strong reason to return, but it was sold before receiving all the depth required to fully exploit that engine. The more updates improve it, the more they demonstrate the quality of its foundations while simultaneously reminding us what was missing at launch.

Physical Machine: Pro Keeps the Game, Premium and LE Give It More Presence

The Pro retains the essential layout and ruleset. Premium and Limited Edition add elements including animated Pikachu, the Squirtle Whirlpool and the Arena electromagnet, together with richer physical staging. The difference is real and clearly improves how much of the licence physically occupies the playfield, but it does not create a second Pokémon experience unavailable to Pro owners.

This may even be one of those cases where the Pro becomes particularly dangerous for the upper models when judged strictly on game design. The Discover, Catch, Train, Battle loop, Story Modes, captures, battles and the majority of the progression remain intact. Premium and LE make the experience livelier, but most of the machine’s software intelligence is not locked behind the upgrade.

Squirtle’s Whirlpool is exactly the kind of Premium mechanism I want. It does not move merely to justify another line on a specification sheet: it holds the ball, changes the sensation of the shot, creates a moment of reading and participates in several gameplay contexts. The magnet and Pikachu also add staging without making the machine feel dependent on a collection of mechanisms likely to need constant attention.

My own decision to buy the Limited Edition obviously comes from something much less rational as well. Collecting can never be reduced entirely to function. Finish, edition, physical object and the pleasure of seeing the machine in the gameroom all matter. But when I separate the collector from the reviewer, the conclusion remains obvious: the Pro already contains a great deal of Pokémon.

Editorial Verdict: The Pinball Machine Gave Me the Doorway Thirty Years of Pokémon Never Found

I came to this machine with no nostalgia to defend. Pokémon was neither my childhood, my video game nor my cartoon. I discovered the licence through my children, then through the cards, before finally meeting it properly under pinball glass. That distance ultimately allowed me to see what Stern gets right: Pokémon works when it stops asking the player to admire its characters and starts making them perform the actions that define their world.

Capturing is the simplest demonstration. When a Pokémon appears, I hit the Pokédex, work through the CATCH shots and reach that final ramp with only a few seconds remaining, I am no longer thinking about the score. I want to catch it. Training then gains a function, the team matters in battle, type relationships begin to count and the biomes give the journey direction. Stern has translated a video game loop into pinball decisions without trying to build an artificial RPG under glass.

The machine remains frustrating to judge because its biggest problem is no longer its game design but the timing of its development. The code documented here, version 0.85, shows an architecture that has become far more coherent through the four biomes, Showdowns and Pokémon Arena. It also reveals how incomplete the machine was when the first owners received it. I accept that a modern pinball machine evolves after release; I refuse to confuse enrichment with delayed completion. Adding another floor later is evolution. Delivering the staircase several months after the owners have moved in is something else.

That criticism should not artificially contaminate everything around it. The layout is accessible and enjoyable. The hardware inspires confidence. Theme integration is excellent. The ruleset now has a strong backbone. The visual experience remains more conservative than I would have liked, and the end of development still needs to demonstrate how far this construction can ultimately go. Pokémon is not currently the absolute masterpiece its licence might have allowed, but it has something far more important than abstract potential: a very good machine already exists.

Then there is the much more personal story. For almost thirty years, Pokémon passed in front of me without finding any way in. The anime failed. The video games failed. My children opened the door slightly, the cards pushed it further and Stern finally sent a steel ball straight through it.

Now, when I miss the final ramp of a capture, I finally understand what all those kids were chasing on their Game Boys while I watched them from behind my shop counter.

I wanted that one.

Thus I have spoken.

Lazarvs

The author

Lazarvs

Fondateur de Pinball Xperience. Joueur. Collectionneur. Créateur. Le flipper comme jeu, culture et industrie. PLAY. LEARN. CONNECT.

View profile