Pinball Xperience

Tim Sexton Takes On the Pinball Industry: Right on the Facts, Wrong on Some Targets

· Lazarvs

Tim Sexton Takes On the Pinball Industry: Right on the Facts, Wrong on Some Targets
stern pinballpinball industryanalysisFalloutKeith Elwinsteve ritchiepinball expo 2026tim sextonpinball industryJohn WickRushLed ZeppelinBlack Knight: Sword of Rage

Tim Sexton: Pinball's Baba Yaga Steps Out of the Shadows and Goes After the Industry

About seven years at Stern Pinball, credits on Black Knight: Sword of Rage, Led Zeppelin and John Wick: Tim Sexton has seen the backstage of an industry he accuses of rehashing its past and turning its back on its players. On that charge, the facts largely back him up: reissues priced almost at the level of new games, a botched launch, a show lineup leaning on licenses and legacy titles, all under the signature of the market leaders. His shots at Keith Elwin and Steve Ritchie, on the other hand, miss the mark.

"Is it just me or does it feel like there's a huge disconnect between the pinball industry and the pinball community?" Tim Sexton drops the question without any rhetorical padding. In his remarks, the former Stern developer targets manufacturers' communication, the recycling of older machines, the Pinball Expo programming and the sector's inability to serve up anything new. The tone is caustic, the timing well chosen. Pinball Expo 2026, held October 14 to 17 in Schaumburg, Illinois, has just closed its doors. Stern unveiled AC/DC Remastered there under questionable conditions, several manufacturers showed their new games, and Steve Ritchie, one of the most influential creators in pinball history, announced at 76 that he is stepping away from designing coin-operated machines.

Sexton carries more weight than the average critic: he knows from the inside the constraints he denounces, the teams, the chain that leads from a concept to a sellable machine. His claims can therefore be checked, and the facts come down in his favor on the essentials, against him on a few targets.

Seven Years at Stern and Two Machines Signed by Ritchie

A former firmware engineer at IBM, Sexton joined Stern's software team, where he stayed about seven years, until his departure in March 2025 for Play Mechanix, an arcade company where he is now a Senior Software Engineer. The software of a modern pinball machine covers the architecture of the rules, the sequencing of modes, the dialogue between mechanisms, lights, animations and sound, and the coordination of several teams on a single game. A great playfield is not enough: objectives must stay readable, progression must keep the player hooked, rewards must stay balanced.

His name first appears in the credits of Black Knight: Sword of Rage (2019), where he is credited on software, with Steve Ritchie on design and Scott Ian, guitarist of Anthrax, on music. That machine revisits a universe born from Ritchie's pen, whose original Black Knight dates to 1980. Sexton follows with Led Zeppelin (2020), on which he is lead game developer and whose designer is, once again, Steve Ritchie. He then appears in the software credits of John Wick (2024), alongside other developers. Two of the machines carrying his software signature are therefore Ritchie creations, which lends a particular flavor to his sarcasm about the seminars devoted to the man.

Sexton built products, spent time with players, lived through the trade-offs of the sector: he has the right to question manufacturers' methods and choices. That right comes with an obligation. Anyone who knows how hard the job is must tell apart the mistake of a management team, the decision of a company and the work of a creator.

AC/DC Remastered: A Launch Without a Playable Machine

Sexton's first example concerns Stern and its announcement of AC/DC Remastered during the show. On paper, the operation ticked every box: AC/DC remains a popular music license, and its first adaptation, signed by Steve Ritchie in 2012, ranks among the landmark titles of Stern's modern catalog. The execution stumbled. Stern had announced an unveiling for Wednesday, October 14, the date shown on its teaser, before making the machine official on Thursday, October 15. The press release landed late in the afternoon, Eastern time, with a trailer still set to private, and a page on the Stern store announcing an All-Access LE sale on the 14th at noon Central was indexed, then pulled, without the sale taking place.

The machine itself was only shown at the end of the Stern factory tour. Sexton's grievance takes shape here: what is the point of a thunderous announcement at the biggest gathering of the sector if visitors cannot touch the product? A video, however polished, conveys neither the flow of a playfield, nor the precision of the shots, nor how the first rule sequences hold up. Pinball is played, not watched. A manufacturer of this size owes a flawless launch to customers paying these prices. Sexton's line about the absence of playable machines does not hold for Stern as a whole, since Fallout was playable and Sexton himself concedes it when mentioning the Fallout Premiums, but it holds for the machine Stern was putting in the spotlight.

A Remaster Priced $500 Below the New Game

The price of AC/DC Remastered makes matters worse. The lineup is limited to a Premium at $10,199 (€9,499 recommended price) and a Limited Edition at $13,499 (€12,499), limited to 500 units. The overhaul led by John Borg goes beyond a coat of paint: redesigned lower playfield, three timed wizard modes (Oi Mania, Thunder Ramps, High Voltage), rebuilt cannon and ball diverter, spinning target on the right loop, full RGB lighting, eight tracks added to the 2012 music list, move to the SPIKE 3 platform with an 18.5-inch screen. That work is real and justifies a price. The question is which one.

Fallout, an entirely new game by Keith Elwin announced on September 3, 2026, six weeks before AC/DC Remastered, sells for $7,299 in Pro, $10,699 in Premium and $13,999 in Limited Edition, limited to 770 units. The remaster therefore costs only $500 less than the new game in each of the two versions, roughly 4.7% in Premium and 3.6% in Limited Edition, and the gap shrinks to €400 in European pricing. The cheapest machine in the AC/DC Remastered lineup costs $2,900 more than the entry level of Fallout, a gap of nearly 40%. Good jam can certainly be made in old jars, but nobody bills the jar at the price of the fruit: at $500 below the new game, the remaster asks the collector to pay for the old as if it were new. Stern owes an explanation of what each dollar of that gap buys. Sexton does not even raise that grievance.

Three Remasters in Three Autumns, Leaders Betting on Safe Bets

Sexton accuses manufacturers of serving their customers "leftovers in the forms of remasters, remakes, reimaginings and re-releases." At Stern, Metallica Remastered (announced October 16, 2024), The Walking Dead Remastered (late October 2025) and AC/DC Remastered (October 15, 2026) point to a consistent strategy: three consecutive autumns, three remasters, all credited to John Borg, with limited editions capped at 500 units for both Metallica and AC/DC. That cadence sketches a catalog policy in which reworking a proven title replaces the gamble. The commercial logic is understandable: small volumes, heavy development costs, picky collectors. It nonetheless smothers creation.

The remaster is not a problem in itself. It goes off the rails when it settles in as a method, when novelty is measured against the old and when the price erases any difference between the two. Four manufacturers make the market: Stern, Jersey Jack Pinball, Spooky and Barrels of Fun. Pinball Expo 2026 offered eight playable titles: Fallout (Stern), Sonic the Hedgehog (Jersey Jack Pinball), Bon Jovi (Barrels of Fun), Cirqus Voltaire (American Pinball), Tales of the Arabian Nights (Pedretti), Yukon Yeti (Turner), Dungeon Crawler Carl and Ender's Game (Multimorphic). Spooky is not on the list. Fallout, Sonic and Bon Jovi are genuinely new machines, but all three rest on an outside license, and Stern rounds out its show with a remaster. The leaders, when they are not reissuing, are borrowing.

The other names on the list carry little weight. American Pinball resurrects Cirqus Voltaire, Pedretti remakes Tales of the Arabian Nights, Turner delivers Yukon Yeti, designed by Dennis Nordman, the designer of White Water (Williams, 1993), of which it is the spiritual successor, built to speak to White Water players without reproducing its rules, and Multimorphic attaches Dungeon Crawler Carl and Ender's Game to licenses. These manufacturers, either anecdotal in size or busy winning back a place in the race, offer nothing truly original or disruptive, but nobody asks them to renew the genre. The obligation falls on those who hold the market, and they are the ones recycling. Out of eight machines, three lean on heritage and five on someone else's intellectual property. To claim the industry no longer produces anything new would be excessive, since Fallout and Sonic are genuinely new machines. To admit that its leaders readily take shelter behind safe bets, licenses and legacy titles is, however, a finding the show's lineup backs up, and on that diagnosis Sexton is right.

Elwin Crowned the Only Model

Keith Elwin and his team, Sexton quips, should run a three-hour workshop to "teach the rest of the industry how to make some games that were enjoyable to play." Beneath the sarcasm sits a kernel of truth: Fallout, a new game, was playable at the show while the remaster waited at the end of a factory tour, and the strongest argument in favor of novelty is the one Stern itself supplies. Elwin is the lead designer of Fallout, Iron Maiden: Legacy of the Beast (2018), Jurassic Park (2019), Godzilla (2021) and Jaws (2024), a run that reveals a recognizable manner: elaborate shot paths, strong interaction between mechanisms and a constant search for rhythm.

Elwin is nevertheless not the single yardstick of contemporary pinball. The genre has never progressed through one school of design: Steve Ritchie built an approach founded on speed, flow and shot paths, Pat Lawlor distinguished himself through mechanical constructions, John Borg through his geometry choices, George Gomez through his way of articulating theme, mechanisms and progression. Crowning Elwin as the universal reference would impoverish that diversity. The argument also turns against Sexton, who knows better than anyone that the pleasure of a machine does not rest on the playfield designer alone: the code, the progression, the balance and the interaction of systems weigh just as much.

Ritchie Takes His Bow, Sexton Sneers

Sexton's criticism then goes after the show's programming and pokes fun at the seminars devoted to older machines. Among the game seminars, three point back to the 1990s: the return of Cirqus Voltaire at American Pinball, the remake of Tales of the Arabian Nights and Yukon Yeti, heir to White Water. All three concern 2026 machines. The others cover Dungeon Crawler Carl and Ender's Game, Pokémon, Transformers, Fallout and Sonic. The legacy of the 1990s therefore runs through the show without turning it into a museum. Sexton also mocks the Sonic seminar, which he reduces to a discussion of the color of the hedgehog's arms, but an audience asks questions according to its own curiosity.

That seminar, held Friday, October 16 at 8:30 p.m., served as the setting for a pivotal date. Steve Ritchie, 76, closed it with a final announcement: "Sonic is my last coin-operated pinball machine." He said he wants to settle in Nevada for a calmer life. The man behind Black Knight (1980), High Speed (1986), Terminator 2, Star Trek: The Next Generation and AC/DC (2012), through to Black Knight: Sword of Rage and Led Zeppelin, chose the date and the place of his departure. With him, a page of pinball history closes, that of a designer who lived through the market's shifts, the arcade crises and the sector's revival among collectors. Ritchie must not escape criticism, his recent creations deserve the same scrutiny as any designer's, but dissecting the limits of a game and mocking a conference devoted to its creator are two distinct exercises. Sneering at the seminar of a man announcing his retirement there lacks class, especially since asking for more talks on contemporary development does not require sacrificing those that preserve pinball's memory. Another awkward detail: AC/DC, the machine whose remaster fuels all of Sexton's anger, is a Steve Ritchie creation.

A Witness Who Hits the Mark and Aims Wrong

Sexton hands his critics an easy target himself. For seven years he helped build the Stern catalog, including the reinterpretation of a historic franchise with Black Knight: Sword of Rage, and now he lambastes an industry clinging to its past successes. Calling it a fatal contradiction would be hasty: a creation built on an existing franchise differs from a remaster, and Black Knight: Sword of Rage brought its own playfield, mechanisms and rules. Still, Sexton knows what licenses weigh and what production compromises cost, and that knowledge should have steered his shots toward strategic decisions rather than toward the people who design playfields. A remaster is a corporate decision, a botched launch the business of a chain of departments: machine availability, sign-off on promotional material, broadcast rights and communication choices are out of the designers' hands.

An Omertà Broken Without a Single Revelation

Talking about omertà assumes a secret has been broken, and Sexton reveals nothing. The staggered unveiling, the private trailer, the pulled store page and the machine relegated to the end of a factory tour are public facts. From a former Stern insider, one expected the inner workings: how a schedule slips, who signs off on a video, how a license or logistics hinder a presentation, how the price of a remaster is set. He delivers none of it, and his free speech comes nineteen months after his departure, from a job at another player in the sector. In a tight-knit world where manufacturers, distributors, creators and the public run into each other at every show, silence has its reasons, and whoever breaks it must bring what the others leave unsaid. Sexton broke the silence without shedding light, aiming at those who design playfields rather than at those who sign off on announcements. That is where he spits in the soup: he turns his experience against creators whose work fed the catalog he helped build, and leaves untouched the communication decisions he denounces.

Buyers at $10,000 Who Demand Answers

Buyers are no longer arcade and bar operators, for whom a machine's success was measured in paid plays. Private collectors now hold the upper hand: Premium and Limited Edition models above $10,000, dedicated accessories, a direct relationship with a highly informed community. They scrutinize the playfield content, the differences between versions, the state of the code, the room for updates and the fairness of the price, follow announcements, compare manufacturers and debate development choices in public.

On social media, a teaser sets expectations, a leak feeds speculation, a delay takes on the look of a state affair. As machines get more expensive, demands rise: a botched presentation erodes trust, a poorly worded promise sparks controversy, a feature announced but missing from the software at launch gives the impression of a product shipped too early. Post-release software development is now a normal part of life for a connected pinball machine, and an update can deliver content that was on the schedule without repairing a faulty product. The pitfall appears when what is available, what is coming and what the manufacturer has committed to blur together. Trust then rests on the quality of the machine, the rigor of the information and promises kept.

A Valid Grievance Drowned in an Overbroad Charge

The launch of AC/DC Remastered was a textbook case for questioning how announcements are prepared, how players' expectations are respected and the price gap between a remaster and a new game, and the show's lineup confirms the rise of licenses and legacy titles. By stopping there, Sexton kept a solid case. He widens his fire to the historical talks and to other designers' skills, and that widening weakens a case that had no need of it. Defending Stern solely because Sexton is a former employee would be the symmetrical mistake. His departure takes nothing away from the validity of his criticism, which is worth exactly what the facts behind it are worth. His career gives him real knowledge of how a pinball machine is designed, but not a monopoly on good taste nor on the definition of a successful game. Players split between speed, complex rules, shot precision, mechanical innovation, audiovisual immersion and faithfulness to a license, and each machine is judged by its own ambitions.

The Pinball Xperience® Position

At Pinball Xperience®, we consider Tim Sexton well founded on the essentials, and the target is the right one. Stern, Jersey Jack Pinball, Spooky and Barrels of Fun form the locomotive of the market, and each earned its rank by breaking with the established order. Stern was built on the ashes of Sega Pinball, a competitor of Bally/Williams, the leader of the day. Jersey Jack Pinball made the lone survivor of that era look dated, with LCD screens and connectivity. Spooky forged a strongly marked identity through the way it positions its licenses. Barrels of Fun bets on engineering and the rationalization of its production. Four groundswells, and Pinball Xperience® comes from the same vein. These locomotives still take risks, but they take them on safe bets: three remasters in three autumns at Stern, Sonic at Jersey Jack Pinball, Bon Jovi at Barrels of Fun, and an AC/DC Remastered launch that stacks a staggered unveiling, a private trailer, a machine visible at the end of a factory tour and a remaster priced $500 below a new game.

The outsiders were meant to bring the disruption, and they are not delivering: anecdotal or busy winning back their place in the race, they offer nothing truly original. The market therefore expects from the leaders what they themselves did once, breaking the codes. Manufacturers cannot demand the community's enthusiasm while counting on forgiveness for their mistakes, and buyers paying more than $10,000 demand transparency, consistency and quality in proportion to what they pay. Sexton could have put his experience to work on the processes he knows: how a development decision is born, how schedules get built, why some projects stall, how manufacturers could tighten their relationship with players. He chose to aim at those who design playfields. The locomotive is who he should have called out: those who changed the game once still know how, provided they are asked to, and asked by someone aiming true.

Lazarvs

The author

Lazarvs

Fondateur de Pinball Xperience. Joueur. Collectionneur. Créateur. Le flipper comme jeu, culture et industrie. PLAY. LEARN. CONNECT.

View profile