Pinball Xperience

Phantom Prices: The Uncomfortable Truth About Used Pinball Values

· Lazarvs

Phantom Prices: The Uncomfortable Truth About Used Pinball Values
pinball xperiencepinball investmentbuying pinball machinespinball marketpinball resaleflipper 2026Used Pinball MachinesPinball PricesPinball ValuesPinball DepreciationPinball Market 2026Limited Edition PinballFlipper occasionCote flipperprix flipperpinball marketEvil DeadMedieval Madness RemakeAttack from Mars Remake

PHANTOM PRICES: YOUR PINBALL MACHINE ISN'T WORTH WHAT YOU THINK

In the used pinball market, not every machine follows the same trajectory. Evil Dead is up 15% compared to its annual average. Harry Potter, Medieval Madness, and Attack from Mars are losing ground.

Same market, same month. Three machines widely considered safe bets are slipping, while a game released in 2024 is chasing record prices. Is your pinball machine really worth what you expect to get when you sell it? That question is going to upset a few people, and that's exactly the point. Between listings with absurd asking prices, limited editions marketed as investments, scalpers, and owners convinced their machines couldn't possibly lose a dollar, the used pinball market has become remarkably good at maintaining its own illusions.

At Pinball Xperience, we have a habit of putting our finger right where it hurts. Today, we're tackling the biggest taboo in our community: money. Your cash, your dough, your bucks, your hard-earned savings, your profits, your rainy-day fund. In short, every last dollar! The money we spend on our machines, the money we hope to recover when we sell them, and, most importantly, the money buyers are actually willing to put on the table.

$12,000 TO BUY, $9,000 TO SELL: THE BILL NOBODY CALCULATES

A player buys a pinball machine for $12,000 and sells it two years later for $9,000. That's a $3,000 loss on the difference between purchase and resale alone, equivalent to $125 per month of ownership, excluding additional expenses. Compare that to a gym membership, a ski pass, or a monthly concert ticket, and the cost is perfectly defensible. For hundreds of games, evenings with friends, and a machine taking pride of place in the living room, that's not necessarily a bad deal. The problem isn't the loss itself. It's the gap between the actual loss and the one the owner expected.

Because that player was counting on getting $11,000 back to finance the next machine. He had his eye on a $13,000 LE, calculated that he would only need another $2,000, and had everything figured out. At a $9,000 resale price, that difference suddenly becomes $4,000, and the LE turns into a Premium, perhaps even a Pro. His next purchase moves into a different price category, even though neither his preferences nor his monthly budget have changed. Multiply that scenario across thousands of collectors who finance each new machine by selling the previous one, and gameroom turnover slows, taking demand for new machines with it. The new pinball market depends on the health of the used market far more than manufacturers are willing to admit.

Pinball Market

The Venom Premium provides a striking example of this mechanism at the level of an individual model. In the United States, its average selling price reportedly fell from approximately $9,100 in 2024 to $6,500 in 2025, a 29% decline in a single year. An owner who planned his resale based on 2024 values saw nearly $2,600 disappear from his budget without changing a thing about his machine. He did nothing wrong. The market simply made its decision without asking him.

Pinball Market

YOUR ACCESSORIES AREN'T ON THE NEXT BUYER'S INVOICE

You buy a machine for $10,000, install a $1,000 topper, add protectors, a custom shooter rod, new lighting, mirror blades, and a handful of 3D-printed mods. Total: $12,000 in receipts sitting in a drawer. A few months later, you naturally assume your machine is now worth $12,000. Except the next buyer doesn't necessarily share your taste or priorities. They didn't choose those accessories, they never experienced the excitement of unboxing them, and all they see is a machine they have to accept as it stands.

Two categories of accessories stand out. Official equipment that has become impossible to find, such as a manufacturer topper that sold out years ago, can command a genuine premium because it solves a problem for the buyer: they couldn't get one anywhere else. Everything else is a gift they never asked for. Cosmetic modifications follow the same principle, sometimes with even harsher consequences. A collector looking for a completely original machine may run a mile from your customized playfield, glued-on figurines, and colored LEDs. Everything you paid to make the machine unique might actually make it less desirable to them.

Maintenance follows the same rule. A clean, fully functional, meticulously maintained pinball machine has a clear advantage over a neglected one, and it will generally be easier to sell. But you don't recover the cost of every repair when you sell it. A buyer pays for a working machine, not for the history of problems you had to fix. What a machine has cost you and what it's worth on the market are two entirely different things. Surprisingly few people seem willing to understand that.

PHANTOM PRICES: NUMBERS NOBODY HAS EVER PAID

One seller lists a machine for $11,000. A second owner sees the listing and puts theirs up for $10,800, convinced they're offering a competitive price. A third decides that their better-equipped example must be worth at least $10,500. None of these three machines has sold, yet a market value has already been established in people's minds. Two weeks later, someone in a Facebook group will confidently announce that the model "goes for around $10,500." Nobody will ask where they actually saw one sell.

That's a phantom price: a figure that circulates, gets repeated by everyone, and has never been validated by a buyer. It feeds on unsold listings that become reference points for subsequent listings, and it thrives in France for a structural reason. Classified platforms and valuation tools show asking prices, not the amounts actually agreed upon between private individuals. In the United States, some sellers disclose the final transaction price, making it possible to calculate averages based on completed sales. In France, there is no equivalent comprehensive public record. A machine advertised at €12,000 for six months isn't necessarily worth €12,000. Until a buyer agrees to that amount, it's simply an asking price.

Pinball Market

Conversely, when someone sells their machine quickly for less, other owners sometimes accuse them of destroying the market. The accusation is absurd. Selling below other people's asking prices doesn't devalue the machine. It means accepting the terms on which a buyer is prepared to close the deal. The seller who gets $9,500 in a week has established an actual transaction price. The other three, still sitting on listings at $10,500 and above, have established a fiction.

SCARCITY DOESN'T CREATE VALUE

LE, Collector's Edition, Anniversary, Super LE... Manufacturers keep introducing increasingly exclusive editions, with specific equipment, premium finishes, and sometimes numbered production runs. These differences justify higher launch prices and fuel collectors' appetites. But a limited edition isn't an investment, and the market demonstrates that with every cycle.

Pokémon LE provides one of the most recent examples. When it launched in early 2026, demand exceeded supply, scalpers moved in, and the American secondary market reportedly showed premiums exceeding 50% above MSRP. A few months later, the same machine was down 15% on that market. Buyers who paid at the peak of the premium were paying for temporary scarcity, not the underlying value of the machine. The Medieval Madness Merlin Edition followed a similar pattern: launched at $13,000, it was reportedly trading below its original price just six months later, to the point that some dealers were reluctant to stock another production run. The word "limited" protected neither machine.

Scarcity itself can become more of a marketing argument than a reality. Harry Potter Collector's Edition reportedly surpassed 1,500 units sold, whereas a collector's edition might traditionally be expected to have a production run closer to 500. A "collector's" machine produced according to demand is no longer necessarily scarce. It's premium, which is a different proposition. A machine limited to 500 examples can lose value as soon as interested buyers become scarce, while a widely distributed title can maintain excellent resale prices as long as its popularity holds. Scarcity only creates value when demand is strong enough to absorb it, and buyers always have alternatives. Someone with $10,000 to spend can compare a recent machine, a higher-tier edition of an older title, a restored classic, or a brand-new pinball machine in the same price range.

Pinball Market

When a manufacturer brings back a historic title, owners of earlier versions suddenly face another competitor. Remakes of Attack from Mars and Medieval Madness have put pressure on original machines, the reissue of The Walking Dead has affected the earlier version, and Stern's announced AC/DC Remaster presents owners of the original AC/DC with the same equation. Consider, finally, a Pokémon LE advertised for €19,999 in France. Until an actual transaction confirms that amount, nobody can claim that the machine is genuinely worth that price.

WHAT THE NUMBERS TELL US: THERE IS NO SINGLE MARKET TREND

In the United States, the volume of recorded transactions makes it possible to track prices across multiple generations. Based on documented sales, used pinball machines sold for approximately 1.1% less in 2025 than in 2024. The decline is modest, but it challenges the belief that pinball prices automatically rise year after year. After two years of strong post-pandemic growth, the market has settled down and is searching for a sustainable price level rather than following a clear direction.

The figures for individual machines are even more revealing. In early November 2026, an analysis of the American market reported a 15% increase for Evil Dead compared with its annual average, 6% for The Addams Family, and 4% for Winchester, while TMNT LE stood 13% above its original American MSRP. These figures don't share the same timeframe or comparison basis, but they demonstrate how differently individual machines can perform. Harry Potter, Medieval Madness, and Attack from Mars, meanwhile, are experiencing downward price pressure. Three machines ranked among the greatest in pinball history are slipping while a 1992 Addams Family, long considered to have reached its ceiling, is gaining ground again. A machine universally praised for its gameplay can decline while another, attracting less attention in community discussions, benefits from stronger demand. Gameplay quality and market value operate according to two different sets of rules.

Pinball Market

In France, listings observed in November 2026 provide several reference points. Godzilla Premium is advertised between €8,900 and €10,100, while Godzilla LE is listed at €14,700. For Jurassic Park, prices range from €7,000 for a Pro to more than €10,000 for certain Premium examples, while a 30th Anniversary reaches €15,500. A €1,200 difference between two Godzilla Premium machines might reflect a topper, playfield condition, or simply the seller's optimism. Editions, equipment, and machine condition explain some of these discrepancies, but they also demonstrate why a single market valuation is no longer sufficient.

One Godzilla Premium listing dropped from €10,390 to €9,900, a reduction of approximately 4.7%. A single example doesn't establish a trend, but it illustrates the adjustment between what a seller hopes to receive and what buyers are prepared to pay. A French market indicator also showed a 1% decline for November 2026, still in progress, following a 1.5% drop in October. The distinction matters: the French indicator tracks listings rather than completed transactions, whereas the American measure is based on recorded sales. The two figures differ in both timeframe and methodology. If asking prices are already falling in France, the prices ultimately negotiated may be lower still.

A PINBALL MACHINE THAT LOSES VALUE IS STILL A MACHINE THAT HAS DELIVERED YEARS OF ENJOYMENT

Some people buy a pinball machine to play it for years. Others regularly rotate their collections, hunt down exclusive editions, or focus on titles likely to retain their value. None of these motivations is illegitimate, but they don't produce the same behavior. When a machine is purchased primarily in the hope of making a profit, its resale price becomes the central consideration. The owner may keep it under a cover, wait for demand to recover, or reject an offer that is entirely consistent with observed transactions. The pinball machine stops being a game and becomes an asset in an investment portfolio, with the added distinction of weighing 130 kilograms and occupying two square meters of living-room space.

Yet pinball has one major characteristic: its value in use. A machine that loses $2,000 on the secondary market may have provided hundreds of hours of gameplay, evenings with friends, and an experience its owner considers exceptional. A collectible watch or a painting doesn't offer anything quite comparable between purchase and resale. That financial loss doesn't erase a single moment of enjoyment. Conversely, a machine whose market value rises doesn't suddenly become better to play. An Evil Dead trading 15% above its average doesn't launch the ball any faster than it did six months ago.

IT'S TIME TO GET RID OF PHANTOM PRICES

The used pinball market shouldn't become a competition in which every owner tries to prove their machine is worth more than their neighbor's. Yet a price decline is often treated as a rejection of the manufacturer, a challenge to the game's quality, or an attack on those who paid full price. A machine that depreciates isn't a bad machine, and an owner who sells for less hasn't necessarily made a bad deal. They enjoyed their pinball machine for several years and are ready to move on. A Medieval Madness that loses value is still Medieval Madness. The game hasn't changed. Only the line of buyers waiting to purchase one has grown shorter.

The market would become far easier to understand if we consistently distinguished three things: advertised prices, negotiated prices, and completed transactions. A seller who disclosed the final selling price after a transaction, as some American sellers already do, would be doing the entire community a service. Buyers could make better-informed decisions, sellers would have reliable reference points, and we could stop pointing to a handful of spectacular listings as proof that a machine's value is either exploding or collapsing.

At Pinball Xperience, we approach this market with the same standards we apply to reviewing machines. Without treating every decline as a catastrophe, celebrating every increase without question, or confusing passion with financial certainty. The real value of your pinball machine is what a buyer is willing to pay for it. Everything else is a phantom price.

So here's one question: which pinball machine do you think is currently the most overpriced on the French market? Name it in the comments. We're all part of this market, and it's about time we talked about it openly.

Thus have I spoken.

Lazarvs

The author

Lazarvs

Fondateur de Pinball Xperience. Joueur. Collectionneur. Créateur. Le flipper comme jeu, culture et industrie. PLAY. LEARN. CONNECT.

View profile